دیںجواب کا سوال اس

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight سوال

TWI-HARDS ONLY (plz like seriously, I may not be a Twi-hard, but hey, I'm the one asking)

OK, Now everyone is going on about how great Harry Potter is and how awesome Twilight is. We know that there are TONS and TONS of reasons why HP trumps all, but what are the reasons why آپ think Twilight is so great? Like, seriously, honest question. فہرست all of the reasons آپ can think of and leave out the superficial ones like "So-and-so is HOTT!" because those don't count. آپ don't see us HPers going "Oh that Fred Weasley! He's so gorgeous!" and no doubt that he is, we just don't do that. Ok, so please, فہرست your reasons. I'd be much obliged.
*
BTW I'm not calling anyone SPECIFICALLY a "Twi-Hard". That's why I'm asking for the people who DO consider them selves that. If you're offened سے طرف کی it, don't complain about it to me. I didn't ask for that. I just want opinions.
boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
 boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
next question »

Harry Potter Vs. Twilight جوابات

italiangirl976 said:
I am not a "Twi-hard" and not obsessed with Twilight. I am still a Twilight پرستار but not to the point were I get offended if someone says something bad about it.

I like Twilight because its a good story. Its not the best book ever, not even close, but I still like it. I like the characters in the book, mainly Jacob. And its a really cute love story. I like harry potter too. I'll admit I've never read the کتابیں but I love the movies. I think that the Harry Potter فلمیں are a lot better then the Twilight movies.

Why can't آپ love both Harry Potter and Twilight? Why does it have to be a constant competition between the two? They are totally different and nothing alike. This just all seems stupid to me.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
Amen, they sucked (the فلمیں did)
boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
The Harry Potter کتابیں are better than the movies. They don't دکھائیں them well, but they get the main parts
potterandtdi posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
I completly on your side italiangirl976 they are both cool but the way people are obsessed with them is driving me insane
Shia19 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
MrsRadcliffe said:
I could say alot. I never say i like twilight because so and so is hot ( btw i dont think rob is hot atall). twilight is a love story, an dthe love that edward an dbella is absolutly out of this world, i mean they would die if the other died, they both would kill for th eother, an djacob, well he is a jerk sorta, but he is loyal and would kill to save bella ( before Renesmee). i've never seen یا read a story like this one. i never put a thought about liking vamps but this story is defferent, is not about the sparkly vampires, is about love, family and friendship. آپ might ask why is it about family? well put it this way, edwards family waited years to see edward that happy with bella, and they would do anything to save their love.i dont read twilight because one of them is hot یا whatevers, i actualy started reading cus of rob, since im a huge harry potter پرستار and he came out in it, i read the book but then i realised that i realy love twilight 2, because of the love story, there is no other reason (well maybe 30% out of 100 because taylor hot, but my point is that i do have proper reasons y to like twilight)
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
i dont call my self a twi-hard, harry potter is مزید important to me, so i dont give myself such names.
MrsRadcliffe posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Harry Potter has مزید to it than love.
potterandtdi posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
I know that
MrsRadcliffe posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
emmaterry said:
sure,im NOT a zombie,brain washed سے طرف کی the shallow power of twilight(also known as a twi-hard)
but i want آپ to notice no twi hard has awnsered
this yet.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
LOL I'm wondering, is that a good thing یا a bad one?
boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Your right no Twi-Hard has answered. A Cullen has.
zanesaaomgfan posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
zanesaaomgfan said:
1. DON'T call ME a Twi-Hard, I am known as a Cullen.

Here your reasons: (I only got 3)

1. Vampires are COMPLETELY better then Wizards.
2. Harry Potter(To me) Is a lifeless story.
3. Harry Potter, its hard to read those thick books! It took a سال from my sister to read a Harry Potter book. (And she read it everyday) Twilight Books, if your real focused, it can take less then a day, maybe a few hours!



**EDIT**
آپ WANT STINKIN REASONS? WELL THAT SUCKS FOR آپ ALL!
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
That blue one, took a سال and 2 months to read, Breaking Dawn, 1 month.
zanesaaomgfan posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
DUDE. READ THE DANG کتابیں
Confuzzle posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
I'm 11 and it took me 6 days to finish the prisoner of askaban. It shouldn't be that hard for a 23 سال old. And it's bigger because it goes deeper than your little chapter book.
totaldramarox posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
VampiresRevenge said:
Before I say why I like Twilight, I just want آپ to know that I do love Harry Potter مزید than Twilight. Oh, and I don't know if I would call myself a Twi-Hard. I'm not that obsessed, haha.

The main reason that I like Twilight is that it is an interesting story. That's it. Not because of the specifics, like the vampires (though I do love vampires), the werewolves, the gushy love story, یا "the hawt gize" (because how on earth can آپ tell if someone is hot from a book?). It's just simply an interesting story, in my opinion.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
Well I guess that makes sense.
boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Well, آپ aren't exactly a "Twi=Hard" seeing as آپ are a HP پرستار and favor the world of Rowling
boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Amen, ladies and gentlemen...
Aquilia posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
MrsJonasLautner said:
The reason I think TWILIGHT is awesome. AND BETTER THAN HARRY POTTER. is because the plot of the story... the whole romance and Bella hanging out with a vampire is really cool, and how there's a whole rivalry going on between Jacob and Edward makes me jealous that i don't live in that kind of world. And the whole way that everything connects just... Makes SENSE. I love Twilight. Always wiil.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
oh yea great reasons , " hanging with vamps and wolevs", i love twilight but, no offence, that is not a good reason, other than that good. btw 4 me twilight isnt better than harry potter, and i didnt know twilight had such plot.
MrsRadcliffe posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Well, we all have our opinions, and I'd like it if you'd respect mine. I just think that Twilight is WAY better than Harry Potter, becuz all of the stuff Stephenie Meyer wirtes makes sense. And when I read the first HP book, it made NO sense to me. I'm sorry. But, I know there are HP شائقین out there who have become obsessed with twilight مزید than they ever were with HP. I know people like that, believe it یا not... And i do think I have great reason, thank آپ very much.
MrsJonasLautner posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Ah yes, a werewolf and a vampire fighting over a mortal...how lovely! <3
Onee-chanXD posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
potterandtdi said:
Thhank You! I'm a HP fan, but here are my reasons:

Twilight is just a love story about a mortal and a vampire. Harry Potter isn't a sappy love story. There's love, but that doesn't rule the whole book! The point of Harry Potter is finding out the truth and stopping Lor Voldemort (Twi-Hards can call him He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named, long name). Is there an evil guy that murdered Bella یا Edward's parent's? NO! Bottom Line: Harry Potter has a better plot. It's not a love story!

Harry Potter has no family. Edward does. In HP, it makes مزید characters and makes them like family to Harry. Edward's family doesn't die! The book has no characters that remind him of family. Harry may find out he has his godfather in the third book, but he dies! Do any Cullens die? NO! Do any Weasleys, Potters, Lupins, and many مزید die? YES(R.I.P Fred. آپ didn't deserve to die!:'( Boo hoo!)! Bottom line: Harry Potter has مزید of a family with the Weasleys and Hermione than the Cullens.

Do Twi-Hards like the book for what it is? یا do they like it because it's new? I'd like to see them say everything accurate from that whole book. Here's what I can say:

"For Him?" Shouted Snape. "Expecto Patronum!" Out of his wand flew the silver doe(and so on)

"After all this time Severus?" "Always."


I can memorize that part from the last book. Are they going to reread the series? Bottom Line: Harry Potter شائقین like the book for what it is.

And that proves my point.


In conclusion: Harry Potter is way better than Twilight.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
ارے I always had a سوال about that quote. Does that mean Sev liked HArry, یا just that he's in love with Lily, I didn't quite understand.
boolander25 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
^ It's not THAT disturbing. It sort of is and it's not ALL about romance, یا maybe it is. But why compare Twiligt to Harry Potter? Just because they're both very مقبول fiction series? Well, then that shouldn't be the basis of the comparison, then. Compare Twilight to another love story and Harry Potter to a مزید adventuous one. :))
Onee-chanXD posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
^Erm, okay...
AprilCandy42 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
Renesmee_XD said:
Okay If آپ really want to known from a Twi-Hard here:
Why I love Twilight and not Harry Potter?

Well from the beginning to end the Twilight saga is a Complex story put into a not too complex language the whole idea of Forbidden Love is something as a teenager sometimes your horomones thirst for آپ know well going through Teenage stages آپ want to be in a different universe. As a teenage I don't really I think much of the majority of us do't fancy reading thick paperbacks with totally diffcult language that is considered uncool. To be quite honest like loads of my دوستوں are now reading Twilight and have started reading other کتابیں and about a few months پہلے the only thing they read was fashion magazines.
My friend offered Twilight to a guy in school he read all the 4 کتابیں in a weeks time. Now he blames her for all that she has done because she made him addicted to reading and now he has stopped playing football.

Btw I only went off Harry Potter because it keeps getting compared to Twilight and I got so sick of it happening that I just went it of it.
But why do people compare Harry Potter to eacgh other they are nothing alike ??

select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
I laughed my پچھواڑے, گدا off when آپ کہا "Twilight saga is a Complex story".
ToyletGnome posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
Okay..
Renesmee_XD posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
i felt like your whole paprgraph was one یا two sentances. punctuation is a beautiful thing, please learn to use it. Also the basic plot of twilight has been summed up سے طرف کی many people on this sight in a matter of words. And HP does not have lanuage that is too complex for my 10 years old brother to comprehend. He may not understand the full meaning but the words he had no trouble with.
potterrox posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
allisoncarleton said:
OK,this isn't really an answer for why twilight is awesome but twilight شائقین have the names twi-lighters and twi-hards and they have different meanings and are in a dictionary. What are harry potter شائقین known as o ok harry potter شائقین real orignal ok whatever. Harry Potter is amazing but twilight is beautiful and I'm not going to فہرست all the reasons because you'd be reading for decades.

I'm a sucker for love stories so this really got to me, Edwards's commitment to bella is adorable and how much they love each other is so sweet.
It's a different story and really hard to put down
I used to hate reading and I never ever wanted to read the twilight کتابیں and I hated bella and I so much preferred harry potter. Then one christmas my auntie gave me new moon and I was pissed but I felt obligated to read it. And I'd like never finished a book in my life and I finished new moon in 2 days it was awesome!

I also believe that twilight does have some independent women (not bella) but I do believe that certain characters represent individual and independent qualities such as:
Leah clearwater
Jane
Victoria
But, I am able to acknowledge that Harry Potter has strong female characters.
When I read twilight it's not to gain knowledge یا to answer the ultimate سوالات یا to find values یا morals it just for pure enjoyment and entertainment, I don't go "Oh I want to learn the meaning of friendship and how to kill greatest evil wizard of all time" It's just a story that آپ can lose yourself in for a whole afternoon. Not all stories have to have a message یا a life lesson I mean Romeo and Juliet is considered the greatest love story of all time and what are it's values and lessons? Oh, I'm 14 the love of my life, my 16 سال old husband just killed himself because he thought I was dead so now I'm going to kill myself. Not every FICTIONAL movie یا story has to have a deeper meaning. Does titanic? I mean it's definitely one of my پسندیدہ فلمیں but what does it teach آپ don't get on a ship that is کہا to be unsinkable. Twilight is just a really entertaining story that I can read all time, whenever I want to. Plus آپ cannot deny vampires ARE sexy! I love twilight and harry potter and a whole bunch of other stories and فلمیں and I don't see why I and other people have to defend why we like a particular story. Kill Bill's a good movie too but no one spends there weekends arguing why it's better than the matrix یا anything. I love twilight and do about 60 000 people on this site as well as multiple people around the world!
<3 twilight

select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
Sorry, but in the terms of "Vampires are sexy!", if it isn't Edward یا Jasper یا whatever, instead Count Dracula, perhaps? Would آپ still think he's sexy? Anyway, I think فلمیں and کتابیں need to have reasons why they exist. Either to entertain us with various jokes, interesting and complex plot, یا teaches us life lessons. Twilight failed in all those three aspects, apparently. Oh, and Titanic and Romeo and Juliet did have a meaning. Romeo and Juliet taught us not to be careless, یا we'll end up like the pair, and Titanic dealt with much مزید than a sinking ship; it's about a woman that needs to be married to solve her family financial problems, though she herself loved another man. It's fine if آپ like Twilight, but the ones that I disagree upon is people stating that Twilight is better than Harry Potter.
Athiya posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
HAHA TWILIGHT IS "BEAUTIFUL". awesome
mickjagger62442 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
I have to disagree with "Titanic has no morals". It sure does! It teaches آپ to be yourself, no matter who tells آپ otherwise. It took Jack to make Rose do that
Ms_Mea posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
next question »