For half blood prince i'll give it a 1 just cause it was the perfect time and for deathly hollows part 1 i'll give it a 9 for everything went good untill fred/george RUINED the moment!
I say a 5 in the movies. I like their relationship better in the books, which I give a 8 یا 9. I never really liked Bonnie as Ginny. Daniel and Bonnie don't have chemistry.
i actally think they could have done better i thought the half blood prince's one was not very good they might have done better now it was مزید of a peck in the lips than an actual kiss which disapointed me deeply a real kiss in that movie was the one with harry and hermione so yeah i would have made it better so a 4 out of 10 kind of disapointed