دیںجواب کا سوال اس

Harry Potter سوال

Harry Potter and the Goblet of آگ کے, آگ confusion.

There are two things I'm confused about in the Goblet of Fire.
First, it says the echo یا whatever of Wormtail's hand came out of the wand during Priori Incantetem, but Wormtail cut it off himself and the wand wasn't used.
Second, it says in the fifth book that Harry could see the Thestrals because he saw death, but it says he closed his eyes while Cedric was killed. How can this be? And when he did see them after Cedric's death, why didn't he see them on the way ہوم from Hogwarts right after? And I heard the reason he couldn't see Thestrals before the fifth book was because he was asleep when his parents were killed, but then how could he remember the voices and the green light in the third book if he was asleep?
 BellaCullen96 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
next question »

Harry Potter جوابات

linhousepotter said:
JK Rowling answered a similar سوال in her official website. Here it is:

Why could Harry see the Thestrals 'Order of the Phoenix'? Shouldn't he have been able to see them much earlier, because he saw his parents/Quirrell/Cedric die?

I’ve been asked this a lot. Harry didn’t see his parents die. He was in his cot at the time (he was just over a سال old) and, as I say in ‘Philosopher’s Stone’, all he saw was a flash of green light. He didn’t see Quirrell’s death, either. Harry had passed out before Quirrell died and was only told about it سے طرف کی Dumbledore in the last chapter.

He did, however, witness the murder of Cedric, and it is this that makes him able to see the Thestrals at last. Why couldn’t he see the Thestrals on his trip back to the train station? Well, I didn’t want to start a new mystery, which would not be resolved for a long time, at the very end of the fourth book. I decided, therefore, that until Harry is over the first shock, and really feels what death means (ie, when he fully appreciates that Cedric is gone forever and that he can never come back, which takes time, whatever age آپ are) he would not be able to see the Thestrals. After two months away from school during which he has dwelled endlessly on his memories of the murder and had nightmares about it, the Thestrals have taken shape and form and he can see them quite clearly.


select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
ashesandwine said:
Ok... so I hope I don't make a huge error that everyone screams at me:P LMAO!
But if I got it right (WARNING: I'm portuguese... with the translation there can be mystakes and so, I can not be the best person to answer; but I'll do my best) Wormtail's hand isn't is real hand but the one in silver that Voldmort made for him! I think that Harry can see the Threstrals because he saw jis parents being murded سے طرف کی Voldemort but I don't know why we can't see them after:S
So... I don't think that he was asleep when his parents were killed because like آپ کہا he wouldn't remember their voices یا the green light!

I'm sorry I couldn't answer the part where he can and then can't se the Thestrals, but I hope I didn't do any mystake and that I made آپ understand Wormtail's hand:D

Hope I helped
Lots of Love
Ashes
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
Oh yeeeah. He DID see his parents murdered.
Mrs-Grint posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
EmilyWeasley said:
The reason why he couldn't see the Thestrals in his 4th سال when he came back to Hogwarts was because Thestrals are only used in the beginning of the year. Thestrals were used on the beginning of each سال to take the carridges with the students. He started his 4th year, then he never saw the carridges again, then when he did, he could see the Thestrals.
He was not asleep when Voldemort killed his parents but he didn't understood what was happening. He was a 15 ماہ old infant. He remembered the green light because it was intense and weird. If آپ try to remember stuff that happened when آپ were little آپ will only remember what was odd and out of place, like the green intence light. The same thing with the voice, young Harry heard his mother's scream, but he couldn't remember it, however with the Dementor's attack it made him relive that moment and his mother's attack, even if he could not remember it, he could remember his mother's scream.
I hope it helped! Sorry I couldn't make it مزید clear!
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
Actually, the carriages are used both in the beginning and the end. How else would they get to the train station in Hogsmead? And at the end of GoF, on page 725 in the paperback book, Ron says "You'd better hurry up! The carriages will be here in a minute!" to Hermione, and it doesn't mention anything about Harry seeing Thestrals.
BellaCullen96 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
oops, forgot that! ok, so maybe J.K. messed up! She's human, she makes mistakes! It's not the first time!
EmilyWeasley posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
that is a semi-brief summary of the scene
BellaCullen96 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
slytheringirl22 said:
these r very gud سوالات n observations but what i think is that the fact that they switched some things in the movie is what got u confused
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
LadyLilith said:
I've wondered that myself!

And while I understand that Harry was only an infant when his parents were killed, if he remembers the green light and his parents' screams than he was obviously at least awake. And while he can't really remember much else, to see a thestral آپ must have SEEN death. Whether آپ remember it یا not does not matter; if someone's died in front of you, that's all it takes.

But I still adore J.K. Rowling. :) As someone else mentioned, she's only human.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
ginny_potter_97 said:
my sister explained this part to me, harry couldn't see the thestrals before cedric do to he was too young to understand what was going on when his parents were killed. and the hiss comeing from voldys wand, will wormtail did cut it off him self. but i think he used the wand to cut if off, kind of like how snap cut george's ear off in the 7th book.



May Fred rest in peace!!!!!!!!!!!!
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
jmillerr1998 said:
Voldermorts wand shows a hand come out because he gave Wormtail a new silver hand and since the wand was دکھانا every spell he had performed recently the hand was one of/ if not the first to apear.
I don't think his parents death counted because he was too young to know what was happening. That or. again, J.k. Rowling made a mistake یا didn't think of it.
And I wondered this as well, it may be because J.K. Rowling didn't think of Thestrals until the Order of the Phenix and didn't notice her mistake.
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
next question »