Harry Potter Club
شامل میں
Fanpop
New Post
Explore Fanpop
posted by coolkatstar
Ever since Twilight came out People have been Debating about which is better Rowling's Magical world of Harry potter یا Stephanie's Vampire drama.People have been saying that Twilight is the new Harry potter but i really dont think so..
They have nothing in common exept they are both fantasy stories and I think that Harry Potter is better and here are my reasons
1:-In Harry Potter
the characters are مزید believable.They have flaws like us for example(Hermione's Hot tempered,Ron gets rude sometimes and Luna's Kind of weird ect)the twilight characters seem to be perfect in every way Edwards good looking ,he is really fast,Rich,Handsome,good in studies and what not?
2:-The Harry Potter stories were completely decided and carefully thought out from the start and that is why every thing tied together nearly whereas Stephanie continued writing Twilight because it was a money maker.
bella has many problems but she doesn't do anything to solve them she just sits there and cries and in Harry potter Harry has problems but he doesn't spend 20 pages worrying about them
4:-Harry allows آپ to fall in love with with personality of characters rather than blinding آپ vision for their looks.

5:-Whenever discussing this Topic with a Twilight پرستار all they are able to say it "But they are hot".I mean that is not really a reason for it.
6:-J.K Rowling created a totally new world for readers to get lost in rather than throwing mythical creatures in the real world.

7:-You can actually learn something worth wile fro harry potter (it teaches us that we should not be afraid from death,and it isnt something we can escape from)

8:-Stephanie thinks her readers are beginners and explains everything over and over again while Rowling lets the readers think for them selves and and figure things out.
9:-Rowling does not offense fantasy writers سے طرف کی completely twisting myths.she takes what has been written previously twists it a bit but in general keeps the idea the same

10:-Harry grew up with the readers and there is actually character development in the series.Harry has learned through the years but سے طرف کی the end of breaking dawn the characters are still as stubborn and annoying as twilight.
added by Hermione4evr
added by Hermione4evr
 The Ministry of Magic.
The Ministry of Magic.
Hi guys, since I had read the book and even written a review of it. So, here are my personal opinions on whether یا not it should be make into a film despite that it was meant to be a play.

It Should Not Be A Film

Since the passing of Alan Rickman, it would be difficult to portray him as Professor Snape as a sign of respect to the actor who has passed on yesteryear despite he is only feature in one scene during the play.

It Should Be A Film

Unless if they get the original choice, Tim Roth to play Professor Snape in one scene, I'm sure that the film will be magical like the play.
They would use special make-up on the original cast of Hermione, Harry, Ron, Ginny and Draco as adults. I would be looking آگے to see the original casts be part of the film again!

The Wizarding World Revisited

So, do آپ want the play to be translated into a film like the گزشتہ Harry Potter adaptations? Please تبصرہ and tell me on what do آپ think?
 The Cast.
The Cast.
added by Hermione4evr
Source: WatsonUncensored
added by Hermione4evr
added by LoveSterlingB
Source: made سے طرف کی me :)
added by Hermione4evr
added by shenelopefan
video
hermione granger
پرستار video
draco malfoy
added by LeviTheAckerman
added by tubby2002