I like Dobby, then kreacher.

Dobby! :D

dobby he rock's

Dobby!! Hes soo cute!

I like Dobby but if I had him 24/7 I think he'd just get annoying.
Kreacher? No wayyy, wouldn't want to live with him.

Winky would be okay.

he'd be my friend 1st

I agree with Mongoose09 but if Winky got into one of her drinking fits, I don't know if I could handle her...

Dobby,beacause he would care for me not just as an elf but more as a friend.Plus,he'll raid the larder for me,and get me all the edible goodies I want<just like he did for Ron>.
Good qestion by the way:)

Dobby would be my first choice, but Winky would be nice too. :)

Definitely not Kreacher though - he's one of those characters I like as a fictional character but wouldn't be able to stand him for too long in person!

Kreacher would be the best house elf ever,he is so loyal and he hates mudbloods!!!perfect:P

Kreacher - there's something in him that moves me. Like the 2 others but this one... Just to see how he could change thanks to better treatment. I must reckon I missed that scene in the movie.

i just dont know too much about winky but dobby would be cool id treat him decent tho they need to eat more its gross that you can see thier bones and id give him a clean pillowcase

Kreacher for sure, he's a loyal elf, not like Dobby, and I don't really like winky

It is elf's duty to serve and be loyal. The only loyal elf is Kreacher. Well, ok, Wi nky could be considered loyal as well, but she is way to irritating, not that Dobby isn't.