Mark Schwahn, James Lafferty, Bryan Greenberg Reveal Where Characters Would Be Now 

One Tree Hill Creator Mark Schwahn, James Lafferty, Bryan Greenberg Reveal Where Characters Would Be Now

Entertainment May. 22, 2015 AT 6:30PM By Stephanie Webber

OTH reunion going down @olevolos #olevolos2015 @thisisjameslafferty #MarkSchwahn

A photo posted by Bryan Greenberg (@bryangreenberg) on May 16, 2015 at 2:25pm PDT

creator Mark Schwahn, and stars James Laffery and Bryan Greenberg kept their bromance going as they attended Greenberg\'s 4th annual Olevolos Project benefit brunch in NYC on Saturday, May 16. At the star-studded bash, the guys relived their Tree Hill days, teased a possible reunion, and more.

Bryan Greenberg in One Tree Hill.Credit: Fred Norris/Warner Bros./Getty Images

The CW teen drama ran for nine seasons from 2003 to 2012. Greenberg\'s hunky Jake Jagielski moved away with his daughter Jenny while former fling Peyton Sawyer (Hilarie Burton) went on to marry Lucas Scott (Chad Michael Murray). But according to Schwahn, the Karen\'s Cafe performer would have made Peyton just as happy. Sorry, Leyton fans!

"I think they would have been very happy. They were a very soulful couple. They were a couple of artists. And they had great chemistry too—Bryan and Hilarie had great chemistry," Schwahn, 48, told

magazine. "She would have been completely happy. She chose an artist and she chose a writer, but not everybody’s gonna choose the musician, come on!"

James Lafferty and Bethany Joy Lenz in One Tree Hill.

Greenberg, 36, quipped: "Jake Jagielski is on the run, I always feel like. With his six- string! He’s, like, in Mexico. I see him with a really long beard."

Jagielski\'s Ravens basketball teammate Nathan Scott, meanwhile, would still be with his "always and forever" wife Haley James (Bethany Joy Lenz). "They live overseas. Nathan was becoming a [sports] agent, so I think they travel a lot. I think the family is happy and he balances home and work," Schwahn explained, undoubtedly reassuring Naley fans.

Hilarie Burton, Chad Michael Murray, and Sophia Bush on One Tree Hill.

"Nathan Scott was that guy who was such a wild maverick in the beginning, but it’s the oldest story in the world: The bad boy changes his behavior for the love of a good woman," he continued. "I think Nathan found Haley, and he was still a bad boy in defense of her, but he’s become a good father, maybe the father he never had. He’s got great kids, she’s a great mom, and it’s the American dream."

Nathan and Haley\'s son Jamie, of course, is all grown up now too. "16 kids. They’re just popping \'em out," Lafferty, 29, joked. "Jamie\'s probably got a sitcom somewhere, and he’s going to be richer than all of us someday!"

The longtime pals have reunited over the years, and still are close. An official

reunion, however, is still up in the air. "This is the mastermind, you have to talk to him," Greenberg said of Schwahn. "Never say never! I never say never."

Sophia Bush as Brooke, Chad Michael Murray as Lucas, Hilarie Burton as Peyton, James Lafferty as Nathan and Bethany Joy Lenz as Haley in One Tree Hill.

, added: "This is what I love—everybody always pins it on me! They love to pin it on me, but here’s the truth: The cast has been very successful, and if you look around, they’re all doing great things, which I’m incredibly proud of. Get ‘em all in one place, and I’ll be there!"

Hear that Tree Hill lovers? Get out Brooke Davis\' Clothes Over Bros outfits, because it may be time to pull out the time capsule once more!

Sign up now for the Us Weekly newsletter to get breaking celebrity news, hot pics, and more delivered straight to your inbox!

Robin Thicke, Girlfriend April Love Geary Turn Hea ...

Poltergeist Actor Oliver Robins Says Costars\' Eeri ...

Please enable JavaScript to view the comments powered by Disqus.

Montel Williams Rips "Slimebag" Josh Duggar in Twitter Rant »

Police Destroy Josh Duggar\'s Investigation Record »

Josh Duggar Cancels Ohio Appearance Amid Child Molestation Scandal »

TLC Takes 19 Kids and Counting Off Schedule Amidst Josh Duggar Scandal »

Josh Duggar Responds to Past Child Molestation Allegations »

Sophia Bush Helps Raise Money For Late Ex Dan Fredinburg\'s Charity »

Sophia Bush\'s Ex Dan Fredinburg Killed After Nepal Earthquake Avalanche »

Yep, This Happened! Sophia Bush Went Topless in a Sexy Bed Selfie »

See What the Stars Wore to Cannes\' amfAR Cinema Against AIDS Gala! »

Cannes Film Festival 2015 Red Carpet: What the Stars Wore! »

Rachael Ray: At Home With the Celeb Chef »

Billboard Music Awards 2015: What the Stars Wore »

Naomi Watts Speaks Out About Working With Women: \'Female Relationships Are Such An Important Part Of Our Lives\'

Ashlee Simpson\'s Husband Evan Ross Shares Memorial Day Playlist That Will Pump Up Your Weekend

Blake Lively Calls Ryan Reynolds a Hypocrite for This Stunt

Kellan Lutz Recalls His Childhood Being Filled With \'Bullseye\' Stunts

\'19 Kids and Counting\' yanked from TLC\'s schedule

Mama June declares \'19 Kids and Counting\' should be canceled as TLC airs marathon

Does Discovery/TLC have a child molester problem?

Josh Duggar resigns from Family Research Council after sexual abuse allegations

Radio host jabs de Blasio’s tardiness at police luncheon

B.B. King wanted donations to poor instead of lavish funeral

Zoë Kravitz’s film ‘Dope’ gets standing ovation at Cannes

Kylie Jenner: Inside Her $2.7 Million Dream Home »

See the posh pads these stars call home

Do It Like Lupita! Kendall, Miranda, More Celebs Twirl Hard…

Jennifer Aniston Shares Epic \'90s Photo, Makes Us Miss…

Boy or Girl? Pregnant Game of Thrones Star Lena Headey Is…

Naturally! Sarah Stage Back in Bikini Five Weeks After…

The Tears! TVD Stars Share Favorite Nina Dobrev Memories…