can we stop killing off Peyton...how about someone like Owen or something...Peyton needs no help with death stories.

hahaha agreed!!couldnt chose between Luke and Brooke!!but honestly i think everyone!!

everyone would be and i think Peyton has had enough Drama in her life i am all for killing Owen.

at first i think Lucas and Brooke would both take it eaqually hard, but Lucas would be hurt for a longer amount of time, and overall would obviously be more affected for the long haul

^^totally agree. obviously they would both take it hard... but i think lucas would be more affected by it, and would have a harder time moving on from it than brooke would. brooke has other close friends that she can find comfort in, but lucas only has ONE love of his life. and that's peyton.

BROOKE WOLD PROBABLY TOO.

and brooke!

yeah i agree stop tryna kill of peyton - she aint gonna die! DEAL! xD

ok so clearly lucas would take it hard....and of course nathan and haley and derrick and jake....but the episode when keith is lucas's guide in the 4th season and you can see what brooke would have been like if peyton died- brooke would have completely changed and become a different dark angry person. and i feel like with the years that have passed, those feelings would only be intensified

^Yeah but Luke could even be worse than Brooke was but we never got to see him deal with Peyton's death. I think Luke would take it the hardest.

also brooke

in that episode where Keith took Lucas around his life and we saw Brooke has a dark angry person after "Peyton died", she was like that because she BLAMED HERSELF for Peyton's death. the whole scenario was that Lucas never went back into the school, and Peyton died, and Brooke blamed herself for her death because she left her there in the school. i don't think Brooke would be that angry of a person if Peyton just happened to die, i think it was all based on the fact that Brooke felt like her death was her fault because she left her behind in the school

When keith tells Lucas that Peyton Dead Is it me or did he have a heart broken look on his face I aways thought he did. Brooke would take at hard as well

yes loisclarkalways.. when Keith said to Lucas "Peyton died that day"... Lucas looked crushed like he didn't even want to think about that happening and like he didn't want to hear it at all. i love that episode for them by the way :)

"i never told Peyton i love her, i have to go back" <3

because lucas has other people in his life... peyton is like a sister to brooke and brooke doesn't have family other then her