|
lightningbarer said:
Okay, there's a reason why people hate Rose and its simple. She isn't a Dr Who Companion - oh, Russell T Davies tries to make us believe she is, does a hell of a lot to try, but he fails - Rose is very similar to those one-time companion's who get dropped off when the Doctor realises it's not about دکھانا them the universe, it's about them, all about them. Notice what I did there? آپ see, the big problem with Rose was she was very self involved, even with things people say as pro's to her should be re-evaluated. Take her rant against Cassandra for instance, taken on face value, it's a message of the insane nature people go to to be different with plastic surgery.(as stupid pop culture was a thing with the RTD era) But look at it seriously for a moment. Rose is a Human, she looks Human. Cassandra say's she's "The Last Human", but she doesn't look like it. So Rose attacks that, it's not like her, so it's wrong! The idea that conforming to a pre-set idea of what is supposed to be normal isn't Dr Who, we see that with several episodes penned سے طرف کی better writers than Davies. Taken from the Transcript of Planet of the Ood. "DONNA: What is it? DOCTOR: An Ood. He's called an Ood. DONNA: But it's face. DOCTOR: Donna, don't. Not now. It's a he, not an it. Give me a hand." In that one sentence, the Doctor showed Donna and us the audience that just because they look weird, doesn't mean they don't have feelings and are people. I generally point my hate towards Russell T Davies, because Billie Piper is a good actress, she just never got anything worthwhile in episodes that mattered when she was Rose. Now that. That is a good character, showed her acting chops and gave her something worthwhile to use.
|
|