He was good in both

True, but he seemed a lot less.... menacing in the Order of the Phoenix.

I loved him in both, however I liked the Order of the Phoenix more because there was more of him, we learned more about his past, got to see him in the past and because he had been out of Azkaban for a while he was a little less manic.

Just because he was in it more.

Isn't he in GOF too -_-

And he's not menacing in POA -_-

He isn't but he looked like it in all the newspaper photos. And yes he's in GOF but that's only as a fire-head.

I like his "I am rebel" vibe

Good in all-but i really liked him in this-he was sooo cute and unnassuming-aamzing always though!

Good in all but i really loved him in The Order of the Phoenix

The Prisoner of Askaban was my favorite book in the series.

Loved him in both, but you get to see more of how he's really like.