So I talked to Dave and he said that he could change the banner, but he'll need for me to make a pick and have people choose which one they like the best.
So here's a call for banners!
If you know of a good banner, upload it here under the name New Supernatural Banner Submission.
It must be a 800x100 pixel JPEG, GIF or PNG.
When I have at least 4 submissions, I'll make the pick and we can get this banner changed!
=D

*UPDATE*
The submissions are closed now. Thanks for all the help guys!
Go link to make your pick!