The Voice vs. American Idol
NOTE: AI=American idol (got lazy spelling the whole thing)
First of all, let’s just say that originally had not opinion on the American idol (I watch but I was مزید of like hmm… whatever; though the whole judge thing is just ridiculous) so my opinion is completely unbiased.
THE TALENT:
Well, I think so far from what we have seen; I think that AI has better talent. I felt that some of the talent on the voice was a little weak. I think if they were in AI, most wouldn’t go past Hollywood week. But دیا کہا that, I have to note the fact that the voice is in its first season. I mean, they don’t have the publicity and the fame as AI, so people wouldn’t know about it یا have دیا much thought about it. Therefore, less publicity it has. Give it a few seasons and it would have as much یا مزید talent than AI. I’m serious, the fact that the coaches/judges don’t look might appeal to مزید people and also there is no age unlike idol.
THE CONCEPT:
I think that the idea that the voice just focuses on the singer’s talent and skill and voice is just plain awesome. That way, the judges can’t be biased towards any singer based on looks and talent. It really is just a talent based دکھائیں and isn’t that the point of these shows. Also the fact that the judges/coaches are there to nurture the singers’ talent is so cool; it really is all about the موسیقی in this show. Furthermore, the people who coach these singers are all so talented and successful; I think this has the potential to bring the موسیقی industry some really bright new stars.
Though I think it would be a good idea, to rotate the judges every few seasons. Cause well, آپ have Blake there who is all about country and CeeLo with pop; if آپ change the judges every few seasons, آپ would be able to have a wider range of genres.
Another plus, is the friendly competition among judges, so fun and entertaining. Whereas on idol, the chemistry has died down. I mean on AI آپ have the every so wonderful and beautiful Steven Tyler and JLo but let’s face it idea has gotten a little old. I do like AI steven tyler and his awesome comments. (which BTW: I will take steven over simon anyday) but it has lost it. The only fun part about AI now is the auditions which is no longer that fun to watch anymore. I find they focus way too much on the heartwarming stories and terrible singer and the really good singer (which obviously is a good thing not the other thing) but the point is I miss the whimsical, funny, make-a fool-of-yourself auditions. I still remember watching William hung and the overly obsessive پرستار of Simon winging we are brothers. That was what was fun. After that Hollywood week and so on got boring. I’m not saying The voice will never grow old but from what I see now, if AI does not up their standard, the voice could be the اگلے big singing competition in US.
JUDGES/COACHES:
Well, after 2 episode I cant really judges the voice judges yet but here is what I know so far.
I think the voice judges are awesome, in particular blake and especially adam. The competition between all of them is so awesome, as they have something to win they have a motivation and therefore make is مزید interesting.
Adam: is just awesome, he could campaign for president and actually stand a chance to win. All the fights he has is so funny.
CeeLo: well lets just say he and adam have a lot of the same taste, they somehow mostof the time turn around at the same time. He plays مزید of a shadow role than the other judges, but with his theme and his experience, he could be the underdog to win it all.
Christina: voice prodigy at 9, this girl definitely knows her موسیقی no doubt about it. Her consistent picking at adam (so fun to watch). And being the only girl and her past make is every girl dream to work with her, so she has the girl power.
Blake: ahh.. blake.. you’re so cute.. and I find it so amusing that so far 3 contestant has sang songs سے طرف کی آپ and your fiancée. Also the bribery with the country connections is admirable. Grabbing one of the duets in the competition, blake seems in it to win it. Furthermore, he is very serious, look at his face when he is listening to the contestants. He seems to have high standards ;D
Now to AI:
Where do I begin?? I ڈن, اڑانا even know what to say. So many judges
Randy : the dawg! Been there for the entire thing. I feel he is still like in the shadow of the other judges, it not very often the attention is on him. Half on simon and his flirtatious hands.
Paula: well she is always lost for words using so much fancy ful voca, I feel like I’m watching project project رن وے listening to tim gunn. Man he has a lot of big words! Anyways, she is just, I actually ڈن, اڑانا know. Its like she was just there to judges on the stage presence.. I really ڈن, اڑانا know what to say about her.
Kara: I actually like kara when she was there. The cat fight with paula and bikini girl, was interesting. Season 8 auditions were pretty good but other than that it went down hill.
Ellen: as much I love her دکھائیں and dory and she is just so funny. She was a really wrong fit to be a judge on AI. She was not totally bad but I think the AI producers could have done better.
JLo: well, she in short is like the اگلے paula abdul. She way to nice. But her chemistry with steven tyler is so awesome, so as long he is there; she is good.
Steven: wow, he is just plain amazing, his تبصرے are really just cool. I find he does a better job than simon. I really do.
Simon: ahh. There is much to say, I sure miss your تبصرے on idea but they were just brutal and some not even funny just plain mean. I happy that on britain’s got talent آپ are less of a jerk. آپ seem to be happier in London and well who would be happy when they are back ہوم after so long. (I’m talking about his case). Have fun on the X-factor. :D
HOST:
Ahh.. there is not much too say. Except: ryan seacrest is still America sweetheart.
Well in conclusion, I think that the voice is better than AI.
NOTE: I apologies for my terrible English, not paying so much attention to spelling and all that when writing this. Also, this is as neutral as I can get. I’m sorry if I have insulted anyone in anyway. I didn’t mean but sort of hard to describe all of it without using a little/ of if آپ think a lot.
So what’s your opinion on both these shows? Do آپ agree with me? Why so?
NOTE: AI=American idol (got lazy spelling the whole thing)
First of all, let’s just say that originally had not opinion on the American idol (I watch but I was مزید of like hmm… whatever; though the whole judge thing is just ridiculous) so my opinion is completely unbiased.
THE TALENT:
Well, I think so far from what we have seen; I think that AI has better talent. I felt that some of the talent on the voice was a little weak. I think if they were in AI, most wouldn’t go past Hollywood week. But دیا کہا that, I have to note the fact that the voice is in its first season. I mean, they don’t have the publicity and the fame as AI, so people wouldn’t know about it یا have دیا much thought about it. Therefore, less publicity it has. Give it a few seasons and it would have as much یا مزید talent than AI. I’m serious, the fact that the coaches/judges don’t look might appeal to مزید people and also there is no age unlike idol.
THE CONCEPT:
I think that the idea that the voice just focuses on the singer’s talent and skill and voice is just plain awesome. That way, the judges can’t be biased towards any singer based on looks and talent. It really is just a talent based دکھائیں and isn’t that the point of these shows. Also the fact that the judges/coaches are there to nurture the singers’ talent is so cool; it really is all about the موسیقی in this show. Furthermore, the people who coach these singers are all so talented and successful; I think this has the potential to bring the موسیقی industry some really bright new stars.
Though I think it would be a good idea, to rotate the judges every few seasons. Cause well, آپ have Blake there who is all about country and CeeLo with pop; if آپ change the judges every few seasons, آپ would be able to have a wider range of genres.
Another plus, is the friendly competition among judges, so fun and entertaining. Whereas on idol, the chemistry has died down. I mean on AI آپ have the every so wonderful and beautiful Steven Tyler and JLo but let’s face it idea has gotten a little old. I do like AI steven tyler and his awesome comments. (which BTW: I will take steven over simon anyday) but it has lost it. The only fun part about AI now is the auditions which is no longer that fun to watch anymore. I find they focus way too much on the heartwarming stories and terrible singer and the really good singer (which obviously is a good thing not the other thing) but the point is I miss the whimsical, funny, make-a fool-of-yourself auditions. I still remember watching William hung and the overly obsessive پرستار of Simon winging we are brothers. That was what was fun. After that Hollywood week and so on got boring. I’m not saying The voice will never grow old but from what I see now, if AI does not up their standard, the voice could be the اگلے big singing competition in US.
JUDGES/COACHES:
Well, after 2 episode I cant really judges the voice judges yet but here is what I know so far.
I think the voice judges are awesome, in particular blake and especially adam. The competition between all of them is so awesome, as they have something to win they have a motivation and therefore make is مزید interesting.
Adam: is just awesome, he could campaign for president and actually stand a chance to win. All the fights he has is so funny.
CeeLo: well lets just say he and adam have a lot of the same taste, they somehow mostof the time turn around at the same time. He plays مزید of a shadow role than the other judges, but with his theme and his experience, he could be the underdog to win it all.
Christina: voice prodigy at 9, this girl definitely knows her موسیقی no doubt about it. Her consistent picking at adam (so fun to watch). And being the only girl and her past make is every girl dream to work with her, so she has the girl power.
Blake: ahh.. blake.. you’re so cute.. and I find it so amusing that so far 3 contestant has sang songs سے طرف کی آپ and your fiancée. Also the bribery with the country connections is admirable. Grabbing one of the duets in the competition, blake seems in it to win it. Furthermore, he is very serious, look at his face when he is listening to the contestants. He seems to have high standards ;D
Now to AI:
Where do I begin?? I ڈن, اڑانا even know what to say. So many judges
Randy : the dawg! Been there for the entire thing. I feel he is still like in the shadow of the other judges, it not very often the attention is on him. Half on simon and his flirtatious hands.
Paula: well she is always lost for words using so much fancy ful voca, I feel like I’m watching project project رن وے listening to tim gunn. Man he has a lot of big words! Anyways, she is just, I actually ڈن, اڑانا know. Its like she was just there to judges on the stage presence.. I really ڈن, اڑانا know what to say about her.
Kara: I actually like kara when she was there. The cat fight with paula and bikini girl, was interesting. Season 8 auditions were pretty good but other than that it went down hill.
Ellen: as much I love her دکھائیں and dory and she is just so funny. She was a really wrong fit to be a judge on AI. She was not totally bad but I think the AI producers could have done better.
JLo: well, she in short is like the اگلے paula abdul. She way to nice. But her chemistry with steven tyler is so awesome, so as long he is there; she is good.
Steven: wow, he is just plain amazing, his تبصرے are really just cool. I find he does a better job than simon. I really do.
Simon: ahh. There is much to say, I sure miss your تبصرے on idea but they were just brutal and some not even funny just plain mean. I happy that on britain’s got talent آپ are less of a jerk. آپ seem to be happier in London and well who would be happy when they are back ہوم after so long. (I’m talking about his case). Have fun on the X-factor. :D
HOST:
Ahh.. there is not much too say. Except: ryan seacrest is still America sweetheart.
Well in conclusion, I think that the voice is better than AI.
NOTE: I apologies for my terrible English, not paying so much attention to spelling and all that when writing this. Also, this is as neutral as I can get. I’m sorry if I have insulted anyone in anyway. I didn’t mean but sort of hard to describe all of it without using a little/ of if آپ think a lot.
So what’s your opinion on both these shows? Do آپ agree with me? Why so?