In the lilo she kinda sorta beat icy

true

Are you kidding me. Flora is winning. I just—

Icy has powers over ice. Flora has powers over plants and flowers. Have any of you seen what happens when ice (Such as: ice rain, sleet, hail) wreaks its havoc on nature? Whole trees can fall down just from the weight of it. Windows can smash and shatter; bones can be broken and entire forest destroyed—by hail that is. Ice itself is deadly. It's cold and constricts the life out of anything that isn't protected from the elements. I'm sorry, but how can vines and flowers compete with deadly icicles and hail? It doesn't make sense from both a logical and scientific stance! I mean, come on!

^ agree~

agree with lovabaltor

No contest, hands down. Winter pretty much always kills nature. Flora's too sweet to really fight back. Icy is powerful as is. She destroyed a school summoned a rot army. And what did Flora do? Icy may not be able to beat 6 people at once (due to being sorely out numbered) but she'd have no problem at all taking down Flora alone. The only reason Flora beat her in the lilo is because she literally had all of Gardinia working against her. Flora only won out of sheer luck.

I dont want to be mean but..... Zanhar1 and lovebaltor, you being a little bit...... I dont know how to say it...... To far??? Sorry but i just saying.....

Flora is my favorite but ice easily destroys nature so that is why I am saying Icy would win the fight between those two. Ice equals nature's death since it is cold and freezes the water in them that they need to survive love Flora but Icy would win a battle against her.

Flora did you see how much she defeat icy

@naturefairy Not really. Taking it to far would be to insut Flora or her fans. Lovebaltor and I were simply stating our reasons why we think Icy would win. Nothing more noting less. Just because we picked the villain does't mean we're being mean. Princess-Flora is a Flora fan and she doesn't seem to mind, no one else seems to mind. And I don't mean to sound unkind either.

@billiam Flora had help from her friends pretty much every time. I'd like to see the Winx face the Trix alone and see how fair it is. If you know what I'm saying.

Icy is a lot more powerful. I find Flora very weak. Infact, I think she is the weakest out of the Winx.

well ice melts, nature does not. there is A LOT more things nature can do. nature can last a long time, ice, it jest can't.

But when it comes down too it, Ice kills nature. In the winter most every plant is dead, the grass is dead, trees are left leafless, and you don't see many flowers. Ice can do just as much as nature as it is a part of nature; ice can produce hail, blizzards, avalanches, etc. Ice is known to produce server medical conditions such as hypothermia (in which the heart will stop and vital organs will fail if not aided in a timely fashion) and frost bite (which can lead to the amputation of certain body parts). Sure ice melts, but Icy's is a magical ice, she's frozen things over that lasted a decent amount of time; on top of that large quantities of ice or snow can take weeks to melt; trust me I've shoveled a mound of snow taller than me in my yard that thing last a little into spring.

No Match... Icy is much more powerful than Flora....

Icy would win.