Harry Potter Article: Harry Potter VS Twilight

9

posted by coolkatstar

Ever since Twilight came out People have been Debating about which is better Rowling's Magical world of Harry potter یا Stephanie's Vampire drama.People have been saying that Twilight is the new Harry potter but i really dont think so..
They have nothing in common exept they are both fantasy stories and I think that Harry Potter is better and here are my reasons
1:-In Harry Potter
the characters are مزید believable.They have flaws like us for example(Hermione's Hot tempered,Ron gets rude sometimes and Luna's Kind of weird ect)the twilight characters seem to be perfect in every way Edwards good looking ,he is really fast,Rich,Handsome,good in studies and what not?
2:-The Harry Potter stories were completely decided and carefully thought out from the start and that is why every thing tied together nearly whereas Stephanie continued writing Twilight because it was a money maker.
bella has many problems but she doesn't do anything to solve them she just sits there and cries and in Harry potter Harry has problems but he doesn't spend 20 pages worrying about them
4:-Harry allows آپ to fall in love with with personality of characters rather than blinding آپ vision for their looks.

5:-Whenever discussing this Topic with a Twilight پرستار all they are able to say it "But they are hot".I mean that is not really a reason for it.
6:-J.K Rowling created a totally new world for readers to get lost in rather than throwing mythical creatures in the real world.

7:-You can actually learn something worth wile fro harry potter (it teaches us that we should not be afraid from death,and it isnt something we can escape from)

8:-Stephanie thinks her readers are beginners and explains everything over and over again while Rowling lets the readers think for them selves and and figure things out.
9:-Rowling does not offense fantasy writers سے طرف کی completely twisting myths.she takes what has been written previously twists it a bit but in general keeps the idea the same

10:-Harry grew up with the readers and there is actually character development in the series.Harry has learned through the years but سے طرف کی the end of breaking dawn the characters are still as stubborn and annoying as twilight.

surbhi-sm10, bdavis98 and 7 others like this

27-5 i totally agree with u Hp is brilliant & there's no way 2 compare between HP & twilight cuz they have nothing in commen apart 4 the fantacy part like u said and yes Stephanie craves fame

LoopyLuna96 I agree. If you're interested in the HP vs T thing, there's a spot on Fanpop where we debate about all the time. Here's the link if you want to pop in: http://www.fanpop.com/spots/harry-potter-vs-twilight

montgomeryraina TWILIGHT WILL BE FOREVER! TWILIGHT HAS MORE SEXY MEN AND THEY KEEPS THINGS INTRESTING WITH THE DRAMA!I LIKE HARRY POTTER, but it can be boring sometimes!

HaleyDewit ^ I'm sorry? How can you honestly think Harry Potter is boring? How about the repetetiveness in Twilight,the shallow characters,isn't that boring?And I don't find someone who looks at you while you're sleeping sexy.

PotterForever ^^ Really, caps lock isn't hard to turn off, you just have to hit the button again. It's not brain surgery, people. And yes, I agree with this article.

Matsy23 i agree with this article i mean the way J.K Rowling wrote the entire Harry Potter series is amazing! just simply amazing!!!!Twilight well.....i find Twilight boring. truth be told i only read the twilight series just to please my mom (she was the one who bought them for me thinking that i would like them ><)

coolkatstar Harry Potter Forever! In every book of Harry there is something new and exiting and twilight it just Okay! and boring! We love you harry!

iGoo Twilight izz waay betre then harry potter bcuz itz got hot boys!!! Gt a LIFE HARRY POTER NERDS!!! __________________________________________________________________ Haha sorry I just couldn't resist....I hate Twilight and all its shallow and so-called 'sexy' characters, I hate it's cliched plot, I hate the way SMeyers uses incorrect grammar in like every sentence she writes, I hate Bella's " Oh Edward I Love you! You're so hot" and then Edward's "Oh Bella! I love you. You smell so funky"... These are just a few reasons why I hate Twilight... So obviously I love Harry Potter! I mean the plot is so well-thought. Everything ties in at the end. Every detail is important. For eg. In the Order of The Pheonix, when the Harry Potter gang were cleaning out the headquarters, they come across a pendant that they can't open. Later in the seventh book, it turns out to be a Hocrux! Also the cahracters have flaws, they have they're pros and cons...all-in-all they're completely believable. I've grown up with the Harry Potter series and I've seemed to have developed a bond with the characters which no other book can duplicate (well maybe Lord Of The Rings and the Chronicles of Narnia), especially not Twilight. I have a thousand other reasons why Harry Potter rules...but I'm to lazy to write them...but in short, I agree with the article posted =)

ChocoLuvr101 I agree with the article! Harry Potter is a future classic and has many amazing twists and turns happening in the series. It is aimed at all ages and thrills those who read it. Twilight... psh... don't get me started on the series. LONG LIVE HARRY POTTER!

surbhi-sm10 i agree with you! especially over the 5th reason..just because the characters are hot,they like twilight? pathetic! HARRY POTTER 4EVER!!!!!!