I really like Carrie's songs, but I prefer Kelly cuz I love Never Again... and lots of other reasons too!

kelly always.

i LOVE then both i just think that carrie is better looking and thats the only reason i picked carrie cus i like the music the same

i love thwem both but i love carrie more

She was more successful. Probably the most successful AI.

Carrie is the best. I have Kelly's CD, but I have'nt listened to it in years!

I like both..

kelly is more powerfull

Carrie Underwood 4ever

neither.

Both, but I like Kelly better!

I like kelly to though

I KINDA LIKE KELLY BUT cARRIE IS SO MUCH BETTER!

She's won more grammys, and I think that eventually she will sell more albums....but Kelly is very awesome and will ALWAYS have the honor of being the first American idol :)

I Love Them Both So Much But, I Like Kelly A Little More Because I Like Her Style Of Music More! I Like Rock More Than Country!

I Love Them Both Though! They are The Best Female Singers From Ameican Idol!

Kelly is my favorite pop singer and carrie is my fav country singer so i love them both

Kelly 4 ever! she is SO talented, I saw her in concert, it was epic!

Definitely Kelly.

Carrie, I like Kelly too.

i like carrie because of her style at singing i also liked kelly
i love them

Definitely Kelly. More powerful voice. Plus, I like her personality more. I like Carrie too, though.