I think they're very close, but Esmeralda is more beautiful for me. I like her bright green eyes, her facial proportions, her body and her wild curls. Anastasia is not as pretty to me personally (I know lots of people will probably disagree.)

Both are gorgeous, but for me Esmeralda is the prettiest animated female ever created.

Definitely her. Esmeralda is beautiful while I can't say Anastasia beautiful.

For me it's no question. I think Anya is gorgeous!

BY FAR! Esmeralda is just barely beautiful, her eyes are the creepiest eyes I've ever seen, her facial features are masculine and manly, and her lips are colorless with no cupid curve. Anastasia on the other hand is the most GORGEOUS animated female EVER! There's not one thing about her looks I don't love.

Esmeralda is very beautiful. While Anastasia is not pretty.

She's beautiful! I find Esmeralda kind of average-looking as far as heroines go.