OMFG, I'm SO glad that Brad got the role.
I like Depp, but Brad IS the right Tyler.
That's just that! (:

i love johnny, but thing that for this role the presence that brad gave to it was crucial...

I couldn't imagine Johnny Depp as Tyler Durdan.

i bet johnny would have made a good tyler, but after seeing the movie, i dont think they should change anything in the movie, because everything is perfect already! Perfect things should be left perfect :D

no i dont think they should change anything at all but if Johnny was Tyler then i would love the movie even more! ♥

oo i would have loved to se him as tyler :P lets make 'em re film it. brad can play bob

Ok seriously, Brad Pitt was awesome... but Johnny Depp was just MADE to do these fucked up kind of characters.

The kind of character you love and hate, who is kind of philosophically insane.

then again, no one knows exactly how good depp would act or how much he would fit the role because we've only seen brad. unless someone watched his audition tape or something.

well I would have liked it even better if Johnny would have played the part of Tyler.

But Brad Pitt was really convincing in that role too.

Anyway, it is a wonderful movie!!

This was probably the best role Brad Pitt ever had, it would've been a shame to take it away from him. =P

one of the point in tyler is that he´s hot, so there´s really no way johnny could have played him