not at all..it made no sense. i never understood them trying to group brooke into the same category or triangle as LLP. as soon as we even heard haley throw brooke's name into the picture for the first time, when telling lucas to stop hiding his heart I was like "wait, what? did she just say brooke? WTF? where did that come from?" lol it really just came out of nowhere, since we had seen zero romance between BL since S3. friendship? yes. but romance? nothing.

peyton made no sense at all for me either...

{at least not in that moment}

I knew it would be either Peyton or Lindsay. It would have been absurd for it to be Brooke IMO.

Not for a second, it made no sense at all.

I was hoping!

Really?? Lucas didnt even like peyton. He was stuck on linsey and then out of nowhere wants to marry peyton. That was so lame! Yes brooke was an option. He was spending most of his time with her,which could have made feelings come back.

The triangle was over in S4 ! Brooke being an option was so stupid :P ,I knew it was gonna be Peyton all along