well they dont look like brook
he he

i've always thought that haley is more natural then all the girls :p

they used to both look natural. but hales has had more makeup on since s5. hil's pretty much the same 'ol natural babe :)

Haley has a lot of natural beauty!

yeah peyton doesn't look like brooke at all
but don't worry peyton, beauty is whats on the inside
he he

peyton piles the make up on lol
they are both stunning though
:)

I think they are all naturally beautiful.....

For surrre.. Peyton TOTALLY piles that make-up on..Haley wears more too but keeps it pretty natural. In the out of high school seasons though Brooke is MOST natural looking, her make-up days were the old episodes =]]

to me haley always has a real natural look but i do tink they are both absolutly stunning if i could have an inch of there beauty i would ne happy

They're both natural.

BOTH.