If I thought the rest of the episodes of the season were good...this one takes the cake! It was simply phenomenal! I loved every second of it...the way Brooke/Julian talked about their future and married and of course Nathan/Renee scandal finally coming to and end (YAY!) and the most heartbreaking one had to be the storyline of Clay's past! All in all Mark wrote a great episode and James did a wonderful job direction it =D

couldn't agree more now i know why mark cried when he wrote this episode and clay sara was so sad the way that ended

i was nearly crying at the end scene when clay put his wedding ring on sara's finger! It was sooooo emotional and robert buckley definitely did justice to it! I had no idea or even the slightest inclination that he might have been married, i thought sara was an ex girlfriend or something! I felt really, really horrible for him by the end it was truly heartbreaking =(

I was pretty much bawling lmao.

OMFG. I'm speechless. Well we all seen it, no need to explain why so i'm just going to say....It was PERFECT.

I can't believe when I heard Leyton were leaving, I had such low expections for season 7. I was so wrong. and I admit that. Although it's still not the same without them.

I never ever thought I would say these words, but how awesome was Dan . And I'm pretty sure I love Clay more and more as the season goes on. That last scene with Sara was so heartbreaking.

best episode of the season

WOW. I'm sorry, i just had to say it, 17Q i almost died with your comment! O.O
Don't get me wrong please, i don't mean this in a mean away, or sarcastic and i'm not trying to be bitchy. But hearing that from you REALLY makes me think how much good the episode was. LOL! xD

But gaah, i'm speechless too. PERFECT episode <33
Love Naley, loved Brulian. <33
And loved the flashbacks. *__*
I was in tears by the end of the episode, Clay is just amazing. <33

JUST AMAZING. =']

And Dan is made of win-- "I'm santa claus xD"
He's awesome ;D

Dan was just<3

but brulian annoyed me abit!

great episode!

It was just perfect! I loved Brulian and I loved Naley <3 But seriously, Clayton! I felt so incredibly sorry for him and in the end I was crying. Poor guy!

Perfect !
Ive actually fallen in love with Brulian <3
I cried at the end with the Clay and Sarah bit, so sad but brilliantly done.
I think One Tree Hill has finally got its spark back.
Absoloutly amazing.

It was so beautiful! Seriously, one of my favorite epi's EVER.
Brulian were amazing, Naley BEYOND amazing, I felt so bad for Clay.. his whole story with Sarah was so touching, and I can't believe I'm saying it, but Dan was friggin' AWESOME! :)

GOD such a wonderful episode.

Best episode of this season so far!<3Remainded me of the good all OTH.
Clay`s stryline was OMG amazing!
And the speach Julian gave Brooke about them being forever.Awww.

best episode of season!
i didn't like episodes before so much but i adored this one..
Especially Naley<333333

Two Words --- Amazing Episode ♥♥
I loved every second of it and it was so exciting..♥

Best episode of this season.Naley,Brulian >3.
Especially Clay's storyline was perfect.
So Beautiful.

Dan-I'm Santa Claus xD

Everything was Perfect <33
Especially Naley.

This episode was just aaammmmmmmaaaaaazzzzzzzzziiiiiiiinnnnnnggg­g! Haha, I got chills like the whole way through especially when Dan was doing the True & False thing...I was just like, omg omg omg! Haha, Naley was adorable and Dan was just awesome! :P This has been the only episode so far in season 7 that was not the least bit boring! Clay's storyline was effin amazing! I was like in shock when I found out that Sarah was dead...but the way she died was kinda stupid IMO. I loved the flash backs though, and Clay was really cute in the flash backs with her! :P I felt really bad for him, and I started to cry when he said that he loved her so much, and he doesn't want to let go of her! Quinn & David were cute too, and a part of me kinda wants them back together! Brulian still hasn't done if for me though. So anyways, REALLY great episode! :P

annnd I agree with SeventeenQueen, I had really low expectations for season 7 without Leyton! I still don't think the show's anything like it used to be before, and the previous episodes were pretty boring...butttt this was one of those rare amazing episode, so maybe season 7 is not going to be THAT bad...idk. I'll stop babbling now! :P

Amazing the whole episode was so good and kept you interested. I love when everyone is watching the tv and finds out that Renee lied, when Haley started crying it was so sad/happy, but I think the episode goes to the Clay/Sarah storyline, it was so heartbreaking and romantic I loved their relationship. Perfect!!

AMAZING!!! I don't even know what else I can say!!!!
Great job, James!!!!

I have never been so happy, like i screamed and cried and omg i was on cloud nine !

Not to mention James did an amazing job directing <3
Loved it so much

What can I say? Perfection!

Best epi of s7!
nice job James;D