Still want him to play Peeta?

SaveMe620 He still looks about 18-19. But as Peeta I don't think I'd want him. I've never pictured Peeta to have this "badass" look, which Alex has. I'll stick with him as my personal Jace though. x)

THG123 Exactly! This is the point I'm trying to prove people! They don't seem to get it through their head.

cleo13491 I think if he were clean shaven and what-not, he'd still look somewhat within the age range. But I do agree, Peeta he is not. Honestly, if he had darker hair and skin, he would be very close to how I imagined Gale.

silver93 No, even if he were shaven he'd look too old, even for Gale. It's his jaw line, makes him look older than he is.

tough to old

HungerGamesLove Oh yeah!! Still lovin' Alex Pettyfer!! Shave and he'll be perfect!! ♥TEAM PEETA♥

CarleeMadison96 I still think he'll do fine with a shaven face and some makeup. Honestly, Taylor Lautner looks just as old.

goatheads369 I used to really like Alex for Peeta, but, after seeing some recent pics, i mean, he isn't the WORST for peeta, but at least in the first movie, he should look more innocent and sweet. This looks more like a serious, hijacked Peeta :)

goatheads369 Since he is about the right age, I think he would make a great Finnick!

Bentlie321 i agree. finnick all the way!!

isabellalala He is Finnick! Exactly who I imagined when I was reading. I don't get why people want him for Peeta, he's too tanned, too rugged (I imagine Gale to be ragged and Peeta to be more of a pretty boy), his hair is wrong and he's to arrogant looking. The way he acts is also arrogant. He's just not Peeta.

Primrose8297 yeah. he could actually be a pretty good finnick!!

meganlovespeeta Absolutely NOT!