She's better as a vampire, so season 1, but to tell you the truth, I'm one of those people who liked human Caroline too :)

With Damon using her all the time, being shallow and since I'm not a Matt and Caroline fan... definitely season 1.

I loved her in both S1 and S2, as both human and vampire. S3 has not been kind to Car, it looks like Stefan has passed his halo onto her especially in the writers eyes. She's not had a whole lot of personal development except for the dad situation, otherwise all she does is screw people and take down vamps hundreds of years older then her. Also Klaus completely ruins her character and vise versa.

I love human Caroline but I prefer vampire Caroline. <3

I picked randomly tbh, I love Caroline in all seasons <3

I'm disliking her right now; which is weird, because she was my favorite female character in season 2.

I didn't like her as a human to be honest she was a little annoying, but it was understandable.

as human she was a little annoying...
so i dont like her in the first season..

i agree with SpuffyDelena

she was better in season 2 in this Season She's Annoying Me

I loved her in season 1 till the beginning of season 2 around episode 14 than I just startd likening her. But recently I hated her since 3x04...she's becoming OOC

I loved her in s1. Everything was so much better when she was a human. But she's still the best female character for me. :)

I DON'T LIKE HER THIS SEASON!

none.

and just in the beginning of Season 1 but I loved her in Season 2.

I didn't really care for her in season 1, but now she's definitely one of my favorites :)