Soo Sad!

Well she has Emmett as a vampire

I dont know. This is a really hard one. She had a good life as a human even though it came to a tragic end. And as a vampire she does get part of what she wanted which is Emmett. It's too hard, I cant make up my mind.

I would rather have her human, because she was not such a bitch when she was human... but I do love her :)

Up until she was raped, she probably had a better life as a human.