Here's how I am planning to do it:

People who want to participate post their top 10 favorite characters here. In about 1 month I will take the lists and give points depending on which position a character is placed. So if Frodo is placed 1st on somebody's list, he'll get 10 points. If Gandalf is 2nd, he'll get 9 points and so on. The character on position 10 will get 1 point. After that I'll calculate all the points and see which character gets the most points out of all lists that were posted.

Here's my list:

1. Eowyn
2. Faramir
3. Legolas
4. Aragorn
5. Gandalf
6. Witch king
7. Pippin
8. Sam
9. Frodo
10. Theoden

Here's mine:

1. Gandalf
2. Boromir
3. Aragorn
4. Elrond
5. Frodo
6. Galadriel
7. Eomer
8. Arwen
9. Faramir
10. Sam

1. Gandalf
2. Aragorn
3. Frodo
4. Theoden
5. Elrond
6. Sam
7. Pippin
8. Merry
9. Faramir
10. Bilbo

My list goes like this:

1. Faramir
2. Eowyn
3. Haldir
4. Gandalf
5. Pippin
6. Theoden
7. Eomer
8. Gollum
9. Sam
10. Frodo

1.Legolas
2.Aragorn
3.Gandalf
4.Pippin
5.Elrond
6.Eomer
7.Haldir
8.Eowyn
9.Sam
10.Gimli

1. Legolas
2. Haldir
3. Eomer
4. Elrond
5. Gimli
6. Boromir
7. Arwen
8. Merry
9. Gandalf
10. Gollum

1. Legolas
2. Arwen (My namesake :P )
3. Pippin
4. Aragorn
5. Galadriel
6. Sam
7. Faramir
8. Gandalf
9. Merry
10. Gimli

1. Faramir
2. Eomer
3. Arwen
4. Pippin
5. Aragorn
6. Merry
7. Sam
8. Eowyn
9. Boromir
10. Gandalf

1. Sauron
2. Witchking
3. Nazgul
4. Shelob
5. Balrog
6. Gandalf
7. Saruman
8. Gimli
9. Legolas
10. Aragorn

Ok, maybe you'll find me weird.

1. Aragorn
2. Haldir
3. Gollum
4. Gandalf
5. Legolas
6. Gimli
7. Mouth of Sauron
8. Witch King
9. Elrond
10. Faramir's friend(i don't know his name, the guy with grey hair who died in Osgiliath...)

1. Gollum
2. Eormer
3. Aragorn
4. Gimli
5. Gandalf
6. Elrond
7. Treebeard
8. Fat Hobbit (welcoming the four Hobbits at the end of Rotk with a grimace)
9. Mouth of Sauron
10. Arwen

It's not easy because I'm only sure about my top 3. Well at least I will try:
1.Legolas
2.Aragorn
3.Faramir
4.Pippin
5.Gandalf
6.Galadriel
7.Frodo
8.Haldir
9.Eomer
10.Sam

Okay, here's mine:

1. Aragorn
2. Gandalf
3. Boromir
4. Sam
5. Pippin
6. Legolas
7. Saruman
8. Eowyn
9. Gimli
10. Faramir

Wow, that was hard!

1.Sam
2.Legolas
3.Gandolf
4.Gimli
5.Aragorn
6.Pippin
7.Frodo
8.Merry
9.Smeagol (in the second movie)
10.Borimer

1. Legolas
2. Samwise
3. Frodo
4. Aragorn
5. Pippin and Merry (not separately)
6. Gandalf
7. Galadriel and Celeborn (also not separately)
8. Arwen
9. Gimli
10. Faramir (only in book)

(I don't like Eowyn.)

1. Pippin! <3
2. Sam
3. Gollum/Smeagol (call me crazy, i dont care) :)
4. Faramir
5. Treebeard :P
6. Merry
7. Gandalf
8. Bilbo
9. Farmer Maggot XD
10. Frodo

1. Aragorn
2. Arwen
3. Legolas
4. Gandalf
5. Gimli
6. Pippin
7. Haldir
8. Faramir
9. Eomer
10. Gollum

1. Frodo
2. Eowyn
3. Pippin
4. Aragorn
5. Legolas
6. Gandalf
7. Sam
8. Boromir
9. Faramir
10. ... Nazguls. Call me crazy, I don't care. THEY'RE EPIC.

1. Pippin
2. Pippin
3. Pippin
4. Pippin
5. Pippin
6. Pippin
7. Pippin
8. Pippin
9. Pippin
10. Pippin
11. Pippin
12. Pippin
13. Pippin
14. Pippin
15. ♥ Pippin!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ♥

xD

1.Aragorn
2.Gandalf
3.Samwise
4.Arwen
5.Eowyn
6.Pippin
7.Frodo
8.Gimli
9.Legolas
10.Frodo

1. Boromir
2. Merry
3. Legolas
4. Gandalf
5. Frodo
6. Samwise
7. Pippin
8. Gimli
9. Treebeard
10. Glorfindel

1. Legolas
2. Haldir
3. Eomer
4. Elrond
5. Gimli
6. Boromir
7. Arwen
8. Sam
9. Gandalf
10. Merry

@MythGal: Only one character per position. Otherwise your entry will be invalid.

1.Leogolas
2.Faramir
3.The Witch-King of Angmar
4.Pippin
5.Arwen
6.Eowyn
7.Gimli
8.Aragorn
9.Sauron
10.Sam

1.Glorfindel
2.Elladan/Elrohir... either or really. I love both of them
3.Elrond
4.Gimli
5.Legolas
6.Aragorn
7.Pippin
8.Theoden
9.Gaffer (Sam's Dad)
10.Lobelia Sackville-Baggins

p.s. A lot of these you'll only know about if you've read the books.

1.Legolas(i LOVE him)2.Frodo 3.Gandalf 4.merry 5.pippin 6.sam 7.gimli 8.Galadriel 9.Arwen 10.shelob i dont care i you call me crazy she is cool