JK چرا لیا, چوری کی SM's character name

youknowit101 Nobody stole anything

sisi_st JK Rowling doesn`t need to steal from anybody she has that thing called TALENT

mrsjb923 umm.. reality check: HARRY POTTER WAS WRITTEN FIRST!!!!! i think, right?

youknowit101 Wrong

jenn17 3rd movie even came out before first twilight book

SpeedyGonzalez XD at troll post but siriusly guys there is no copy right ownership with names

HecateA Okay, let's be honnest here, 'Black' isn't the most uncommon name in the world. But HP was around way before Twilight and it'll be around way after Twiligh6 ( ;) )

Drisina Pffff it's a troll post , seriously are you fighting on which person used the Black name first ?

xDark_Angelx Black isn't even an uncommon last name, so either way, neither of them stole anything. -.-

missceleb86 u mean stephanie stole sirius's last name

RavenclawRocks So did Rebecca copy Meyer?

jenn17 ^and her talent too, obviously

BellaLovett ^lol

XxXrachellXxX HP was written before Twilight, you know...

snapeislove LOL. it says "Troll Post." What's with the fuss? really?

hi_its_me_15 Just saying.. Harry Potter was written before Twilight

Potter_Head97 Pfffttt... what a bad argument;) Harry Potter was written way before Twilight, js.

dottzie36 And it wasn't just Sirius'name lol she also put him on a motorbike and turned him into what is essentially a dog

youknowit101 You guys are making great arguments, keep up the great work

zanhar1 You all know there's a reason this is cretited trollposts right?

ange101 no its the other way sm stole jk surname first it was jk then sm

cml999 seriously u guys! It's not just sirius' name she 'stole' but anyway who cares? If you don't like twilight wat's the point in arguing about it??

GoodPunchMione I don't know how many I've seen about this. Sirius Black was mentioned in Prisoner of Azkaban, which was released in July 8, 1999. However, the first Twilight book came out on Oct. 5, 2005. So your argument is invalid. I should add on that the Prisoner of Azkaban movie came out before the first Twilight book (May 31, 2004). Get the facts right before you call someone out on doing something they didn't. I'm not saying Twilight copied Harry Potter, but please, don't randomly say that Harry Potter copied Twilight.

QueenOfFreaks13 This is the stupidest thing ever. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban was written in 1999. Twilight was written in 2005.

zanhar1 For one thing this was posted as a joke. For seconds Black is such a common last name, it's all over literature. God, if I had a dollar for every time I read a book with a werewolf named 'Derek' I'd be rich.