دیںجواب کا سوال اس

Harry Potter سوال

do u agree?

i heard on a rowling's interview that she doesn't consider snape as a hero... she کہا "yes he was brave, but i don't think of him as the good guy یا a hero in the hp series..." at least that was the general meaning... what do u think about it?
 do u agree?
 Irina92 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
next question »

Harry Potter جوابات

Brysis said:
I THINK SHE IS INSANE!!!!!!!!!!
OMG i didn´t know she thought about Severus in that way!! He´s MY hero, he was a hero!! HE IS A HERO!!!!!!!
Severus loved Lily untill the very end and he protected Harry for her, he sacrifice all of his life to do that and he was SO brave and a great wizard! How can J.K. say that???
Damn آپ Rowling
I can´t even believe she کہا that...
select as best answer
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
JustMe7 said:
I was quite surprised when I first heard that, but in ways I think it's true. Because in another interview I heard, J.K. Rowling کہا something along the lines that had Snape not loved Lily, he wouldn't have done any of what he did to help save Harry. So, in a way, I guess he's not a good guy یا a hero, because you'd expect them people to help without self-gain یا سیکنڈ thought about it. I love Snape's character, though, and it's his personality as it is that does that. So, I don't think the knowledge that he isn't necessarily a hero makes him any less of a great character. I suppose آپ could call him a conflicted hero. :) I really loved how آپ didn't know whether he was on Harry's side یا not until the end; it just added to the already climatic atmosphere! :)
select as best answer
 I was quite surprised when I first heard that, but in ways I think it's true. Because in another interview I heard, J.K. Rowling کہا something along the lines that had Snape not loved Lily, he wouldn't have done any of what he did to help save Harry. So, in a way, I guess he's not a good guy یا a hero, because you'd expect them people to help without self-gain یا سیکنڈ thought about it. I love Snape's character, though, and it's his personality as it is that does that. So, I don't think the knowledge that he isn't necessarily a hero makes him any less of a great character. I suppose آپ could call him a conflicted hero. :) I really loved how آپ didn't know whether he was on Harry's side یا not until the end; it just added to the already climatic atmosphere! :)
posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک 
*
yep! i was just surprised سے طرف کی wat rowling said... but you've got a point, in a way he's not a real hero.. thx for answering anyway!:)
Irina92 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
*
No problem, and yeah, me too. :) I never really thought about it before, but when آپ look at it, it's hard to tell whether he's a hero یا not. :)
JustMe7 posted پہلے زیادہ سے سال ایک
next question »